March 23, 2008
About the Event
by Susie Erani
by Susie Erani
Many of us have wondered about the halakhic position on organ donation. Donating organs seems consistent with Jewish values yet the general attitude appears to be “Jews don’t do that”. Rabbi Haber addressed this topic in his introduction to a balanced and thought provoking program that took place at Kol Israel on March 24. The speakers were able to dispel some misconceptions and show how vitally important donated organs are to so many.
Dr. Teddy Silvera spoke from a medical perspective. He emphasized the tremendous need for organs as many patients wait for years because there are not enough donated organs. He also spoke about how successful many transplants are and the excellent quality of life the patients acquire.
Mrs. Pat Mann gave a moving account of her own experiences as a liver recipient 18 years ago. Seeing a healthy, vibrant woman stand before us and hearing her speak was very powerful and made the issue hit close to home. She turned what would have been a theoretical discussion into reality for us.
Our keynote speaker was Rabbi Dr. Eddie Reichmann, Associate Professor of Emergency Medicine at Montefiore Medical Center and Associate Professor of Philosophy and History of Medicine at the Albert Einstein College of Medicine of YU.
A wonderful speaker, he outlined the separate medical and halakhic issues associated with two types of donations – those from living donors and those from deceased donors.
In terms of living donors, the halakhic issue centers on the risk the donor will incur by donating. Rabbi Dr. Reichmann stressed that one has to understand medicine in order to understand the halacha and be able to assess the risk. He cited Rabbinic sources in order to explore the obligation one has to save someone.
For deceased or cadaveric donation, the issue is whether or not one is halakhically dead. Many laws about handling the deceased can be violated for the sake of Pikuach Nefesh. Therefore organ donation may be permitted as long as one is halakhically dead. He cited the Chief Rabbinate’s decision that brain stem death is death. He discussed new frontiers in transplants and the different issues bound to arise. For more information contact the Halakhic Organ Donation Society at www.hods.org.
This fascinating lecture was sponsored by Dr. Teddy Silvera in memory of his brother Jack Silvera.
~Sponsored by Dr.& Mrs. Teddy Silvera in memory of his brother Jack Silvera~